Muhammad was a prophet?

On average, everyone disagrees with nonconsensus between 204 voters.

Disagree Agree

---

Please read the comments from other voters below, then scroll down make your decision. Do you agree or disagree with the following statement?

Muhammad was a prophet

You need to register a voting profile or login before you can vote.

---

Reasons To Disagree He didn't exist. He is a character from a fictional book. 9 February 2012 The deities of Judaism, Christianity and Islam were most likely ancient aliens. 11 February 2012 He was a boxer 25 February 2012 Try filling out 'Jedi' in an Islamic Census.If you were born to a Muslim father that would make you an apostate thus 'deserving' of the death penalty. 31 July 2012 I don't believe in Muhammed 28 November 2012 Same as Moses and Jesus. 5 January 2013 The existence of a conscious god is ridiculously thin so prophet too. 23 April 2014 in an archaic religion, yes. but that is not what i beleive 21 November 2014 There are no prophets only people who do things 27 June 2015 Based on the actions of many of his followers he was definitely on the Dark Side 5 August 2015 It was a fabrication from the Christian church 14 December 2015 He was a man like any other man. 2 August 2016 Just a man kinda a terrorist if you read about him 11 November 2017 Big no. 10 March 2020 Not with Jediism 26 January 2024

Reasons To Agree Muhammad sought to correct what was as he called gone astray. This is why the bible and holy qu'ran coincide with eachother. They teach just about the same thing. If you haven't read the both of them then you would not know this. Muslims once followed the bile itself before the holy qu'ran was revealed through the use of telepathy. This is why he went crazy! 5 March 2011 MUHAMMAD WAS A JEDI, ALSO JEDI HAVE BEEN AROUND FOR CENTURIES WHAT WE NOW CALL A JEDI HAS LITTLE MEANING TO HOW THE FORCE WILLS US AND I BELIEVE THAT A JEDI IS A POLITICALLY CORRECT WAY SAYING A FOLLOWER OF ONE 24 March 2011 I believe so 20 May 2011 jesus prophesied muhammad would succeed him but after muhammad and his followers are gone they would be corrupted by the sith 13 December 2012 every religion has parts of the truth. if you have many different pleople saying the same thing, most likely what they are saying is the truth. if another religion is saying something that agrees with something another religion is saying it should not be dismissed because "its not the jedi way" it should be studied and imbraced so it might lead the jedi to new light and understanding 1 January 2015

Reasons for Remain Neutral

To zealots of Islam yes.

I dont understand the question. Of Islam? Yes. Of Jedi Church? No. Why is this in here???

Not of the Force. Of some other religion, sure.

Muhammad was an open-minded as well as Abraham. He was a trial before Jesus, but his message was misunderstood by most of his followers. Some of them turned to the dark side instead of increase the goodness and living values.

He was not a Jedi. He was Islamic. It is not the same thing. The prophets are not the same.

He might have been a prophet but he was not a jedi.

probably but since he was alive sevral thousand years ago and ive never spoken to him i have no way of knowing

he may have been, but any followers preaching violence are subject to question

Same, as Jesus. He could either be a man who tried to spread his message across about religion or was a messenger.

I do not know enough to really say... But, as with the others, he had some wisdom worth listening to. It does not matter to me whether he was a prophet or not - I am not Muslim.

My comment remains the same. We are all prophets if we understand the cyclical propertues of the universe.

He was a character in a story where he was portrayed as a prophet

not my concern

Whether or not he is real is of no consequence, the teachings are the important part. But I remain neutral because said teachings are open for interpretation and based upon the individuals person views. And those views are valid as long as they don’t diminish another’s quality of life or their value.

As with the other two, it cannot be known truly one way or the other if events in these stories were real or distorted versions of the truth. All we can say for sure is there is a guy in a story who was said to be a prophet.

My View

You can make your comments once you have voted.

You need to register a voting profile or login before you can vote.

Back to all voting categories or
Back to "Scripture and Belief"